Search This Blog

Sunday, 19 July 2015

Writing – editing – evolution of a story

Yesterday’s short story ‘Bubbles’ didn’t start out at that length. It evolved as the characters moved around in my head. Here are four versions of the beginning, offered with a few comments at the end of each in the hope that they might prove of interest.

Extract from first short story version, 1,000 words (April 2007):

Josh Mason’s life seemed to be beset with bubbles so much that he ended up with that sobriquet. ‘Bubbles’ was an ill-fitting nick-name as he was more morose than bubbly by nature, yet the monicker kind of stuck.

We was kids together in the little Nebraska town of Stiller’s Lookout and spent our long hot summers swimming in the creek, stealing Mr Johanssen’s apples and ogling the Fitzpatrick sisters.

I should qualify that about swimming, I suppose. Josh never learnt to swim. He sure did try, but he just tended to sink. You’d think with him being so round – rotund, some polite folk called it – he’d just float like a balloon or a ball. But he just sank. He spluttered, gyrated his arms and hands in a frenzy but still managed to sink. Always leaving behind lots of bubbles.

I lost count of the number of times I fished him out of the deep part of the creek, but I reckon I pulled him out at least a hunerd.

“What you go an’ do that for, Scott!” he’d exclaim when he got his breath back, bubbles of saliva flecking his lips. ‘I was that near to learnin’ to swim!”

“One of these days, Josh, I’ll leave you – or maybe I won’t be here to save your hide. Then you’ll be sorry!”

Fortunately, our friendship was solid and these disagreements amounted to squat.

This was the first version, written for a Writers’ Circle prompt with the title ‘Bubbles’. The brief was for a 1,000-word story. It told the whole story up to the death of Josh though somewhat briefly and missed out some escapades that would be created later. The emphasis is on ‘tell’ here – though to some extent this is personalised by being in the first person.
        
***

Same beginning, but for a longer version, 2,400 words (April 2007):

Josh Mason’s life seemed to be beset with bubbles so much that he ended up with that sobriquet. ‘Bubbles’ was an ill-fitting nick-name as he was more morose than bubbly by nature, yet the monicker kind of stuck.

We was kids together in our Nebraska Territory farms just south of Stiller’s Lookout and spent many of our long hot summers swimming in one of them creeks off of the Platte, stealing Mr Johanssen’s apples and ogling the Fitzpatrick sisters, who seemed to have legs so long they fair went to heaven.

I should qualify that about swimming, I suppose. Josh never learnt to swim. He sure did try, but he just tended to sink. You’d likely reckon that with him being so round – rotund, some polite folk called it – he’d just float like a balloon or a ball. But for some obscure scientific reason he just sank. He spluttered and gyrated his arms and hands in a frenzy but still managed to sink. Always leaving behind on the surface lots of bubbles.

I lost count of the number of times I fished him out of the deep section of the creek, but I reckon I pulled him out at least a hunerd.

“What you go an’ do that for, Scott!” he’d exclaim when he got his breath back, bubbles of saliva flecking his lips, the water sluicing off of his dungarees. ‘I was that near to learnin’ to swim!”

My tone was likely as not exasperated. “One of these days, Josh, I’ll leave you – or maybe I won’t be here to save your hide. Then you’ll be sorry!”

You’ll save me?” He laughed and softly punched my upper arm. “Yeh, all right, if you say so!”

As usual, I let it go. Pride was somethin’ awful, ’specially when you was young.

Fortunately, our friendship was rock solid and in the scheme of things these disagreements amounted to squat.

This longer version is more descriptive in parts. And I added a little more dialogue to enhance character and relationship.

***
Same beginning, but from a third person point of view, slightly longer version, 3,000 words (April 2007):

Josh Mason’s life seemed to be beset with bubbles so much that he ended up with that sobriquet. ‘Bubbles’ was an ill-fitting nick-name as he was more morose than bubbly by nature, yet the monicker stuck.

Scott Finley and Josh were kids together on their neighbouring Nebraska Territory farms just south of the small township of Stiller’s Lookout. They spent many a long hot summer skylarking in one of those creeks off the Platte, stealing Mr Johansson’s apples and ogling the Fitzpatrick sisters, whose legs seemed so long that they fair went to heaven.

While Scott was a good swimmer, Josh never learned. He tried, but he just tended to sink. As Scott remarked more than once, ‘You’d likely reckon that with Josh being so round – rotund, some polite folk called it – he’d just float like a balloon or a ball.’ But for some obscure scientific reason he just sank. He spluttered and gyrated his arms and hands in a frenzy but still managed to sink. Always leaving behind on the surface lots of bubbles.

Scott soon lost count of the number of times that he fished Josh out of the deep section of the creek, but he reckoned it was at least a hundred.

‘What you go an’ do that for, Scott!’ Josh exclaimed when he got his breath back, bubbles of saliva flecking his lips, the water sluicing off of his dungarees. ‘I was that near to learnin’ to swim!’

Scott’s tone was close to being exasperated as he replied, ‘One of these days, Bub, I’ll leave you be – or maybe I won’t be here to save your hide. Then you’ll be sorry!’

You’ll save me?’ Josh laughed and softly punched his friend’s upper arm. ‘Yeh, all right, if you say so!’

As usual, Scott let it go. Pride was somethin’ awful, Scott opined, ’specially when you was young.

Fortunately, their friendship was rock solid and in the scheme of things these disagreements amounted to squat.

I felt I might not be able to sustain a first-person narrative for a longer version so opted to attempt an omniscient third person POV. By its nature, this is going to involve ‘tell’ as well as ‘show’. Most of the ‘show’ will be in the revealed emotions and in their speech. Again, more description is included. And here I introduce Scott’s nickname for Josh, ‘Bub’.

***

Final version, still in the third person POV, and much longer, at almost 6,000 words (May 2007):

Last night’s storm had swollen the river and it seemed to be rising by the minute as they herded the longhorns into the fast-running shoals. ‘Keep movin’, movin!’ Josh Mason barked. He was a big-boned man and, though he’d lost a lot of puppy fat, he was still overweight. Guiding his whickering horse among the steers, he boldly continued to chivvy along the fearful critters with shouts and whistles. On the other side of the broad wedge of beef on the hoof his best pal, Scott Finley, was also persuading the cattle to keep moving. Fording the river now was dangerous, but Boss Fairweather and his foreman Stratton had been adamant, they couldn’t risk wasting the time to wait for the water to subside or even to skirt round the river. To mitigate against disaster, they forded obliquely down stream, hopeful that the action of the water against the steers would assist them in getting across. Yet every faltering step the animals took, there was the strong possibility of one or more of them losing their footing.

            Josh was tired after spending several hours helping to quell a stampede when the critters had been spooked by forked lightning that made night into day. Otherwise he might have noticed the cut cinch on his saddle caused by a horn during the rain-drenched mêlée last night. Now the strain proved too much for it and the cinch broke when Josh was midway across.

            Without warning, saddle and rider slid sideways. Josh’s shoulder hit the side of beef and then he plunged into the water with an almighty splash.

            Amidst the roiling water there was only a cluster of bubbles where Josh had been. Nothing else. Not even a gloved hand thrust through the surface.

‘Bub!’ Scott exclaimed, using a truncated version of Josh’s nick-name.

Boss Fairweather and his foreman turned in their saddles and stared, alarmed, then settled back to their work and hastened to get the steers to the other side before they all panicked and were lost.

‘Damn you to hell, Bub!’ Scott growled. He didn’t hesitate but gently guided his mount through the loosely packed bodies of the steers. He knew there was no point in watching the diminishing number of bubbles, waiting for Josh appear. Unbuckling his gun-belt, he snagged it on the pommel and gulped in a big breath and dove in after Josh.

Luckily, he’d had plenty of practice and though the river was running fast and visibility was real bad, his questing fingers found his friend’s leather vest. He closed his hand round the material and, fearing that the water in his boots would drag him down and his lungs would burst, he gave a tremendous kick and pushed himself upwards with all his might, hauling Josh with him to the surface.

In a welter of splashing water and bubbles, they burst into air that was hardly fresh, since a dense miasma of cattle-odour hovered over the river’s surface. Barely conscious, Josh was spluttering and struggling in Scott’s grip.

It wasn’t easy, since he had to restrain his friend’s panicky gyrating arms, but Scott finally heaved Josh to the opposite bank. Fortunately, their horses were sensible and well-trained and obediently followed. Scott collapsed in the mud, gasping for breath. Lying alongside him, Josh disgorged his breakfast and a fair portion of the muddy river water.

            Scott got no thanks from Josh and he hadn’t expected any. Just the usual: “Why’d you pull me out, Scott? I near swum to the surface!”

            That got a few laughs from the watching cowpokes and then, in high dudgeon, Josh dragged his horse away.

            Once the cattle were back on dry land, Scott and Josh ‘Bubbles’ Mason trawled the river-bed with weighted lariats and, after about half an hour, Scott snagged something. An air-pocket must have been caught in the saddle-bags and a clutch of bubbles burst on the surface.

            ‘It’s ’bout time you learnt to swim, Bub!’ Scott remonstrated as he waded into the river. With nifty rope-work he finally pulled his friend’s saddle out.

            ‘Christ-sakes, you know I damn-well try, Scott!’

            ‘Yeah, if tryin’ was all there was to it, you’d swim like a fish!’ Scott dumped the saddle in the mud and stalked away to dry off.
 

Josh Mason’s life seemed to be beset with bubbles so much that he ended up with that sobriquet. ‘Bubbles’ was an ill-fitting nick-name as he was more morose than bubbly by nature, yet the moniker stuck.

Scott and Josh were kids together on their neighbouring Nebraska Territory farms just south of the small township of Stiller’s Lookout. They spent many a long hot summer stealing Mr Johansson’s apples and ogling the Fitzpatrick sisters, whose legs seemed so long that they fair went up to heaven. In contrast, they also had simple fun blowing bubbles with sticks and soap and skylarking in one of the creeks off the Platte,

While Scott was a good swimmer, Josh never mastered the skill. He tried, but he just tended to sink. As Scott remarked more than once to those who witnessed Josh’s doomed attempts, ‘You’d likely reckon that with Josh being so round – rotund, some polite folk call it – he’d just float like a balloon or a ball.’ But for some obscure scientific reason he just sank. He spluttered and wind-milled his arms and hands in a fearful frenzy but still managed to sink. Always leaving behind on the surface lots of bubbles.

Scott soon lost count of the number of times that he fished Josh out of the deep part of the creek, but he reckoned it was at least a hundred.

‘What you go an’ do that for, Scott!’ Josh exclaimed when he got his breath back, bubbles of saliva flecking his lips, the water sluicing off of his dungarees. ‘I was that near to learnin’ to swim!’

Scott’s tone was close to being exasperated as he replied, ‘One of these days, Bub, I won’t be here to save your hide. Then you’ll be sorry!’

You’ll save me?’ Josh laughed and softly punched his friend’s bicep. ‘Yeh, all right, if you say so!’

As usual, Scott let it go. Pride was somethin’ awful, ’specially when you was young. Fortunately, their friendship was rock solid and in the scheme of things Scott reckoned that these disagreements amounted to squat.

Obviously, this version has departed from the others regarding the beginning. I decided to include some action – action reveals character and relationships. The action is also intended to put the reader in the scene. This new beginning doesn’t mean that the original had to be jettisoned; it is inserted after the action scene, providing back-story.

***

Write a Western in 30 Days – with plenty of bullet points! – is still available as a paperback and e-book (some readers have purchased both versions!)

Amazon.COM - here

Review extracts:

‘…what struck me was that this wasn't just a book of guidelines and tid bits for someone attempting a western, this is a fantastic map to anyone who wants to dive into the world of genre fiction. ‘

‘Over the years I've read a great many books about writing, but this is without doubt one of the finest works that I've had the pleasure to read. While, as the title suggests, the book focuses primarily on westerns much of the knowledge and tips within can be transposed over to any genre.

Amazon UK – here

Review extracts:

‘Although this book focuses on writing westerns it is useful for all types of novel writing…’

‘… I used to think the best books about writing were Stephen King's On Writing and David Morrell's The Successful Novelist. It is time to add a third and this is the book.’

No comments: